While management of intracranial aneurysms has been the domain of neurosurgeons, relatively recent advances in endovascular therapy highlight the importance of radiologists in the diagnosis and treatment of cerebral aneurysms. The author reviews the clinical management of patients with intracranial aneurysms and discusses the imaging considerations and therapeutic options.
Intracranial aneurysms are relatively common, occurring in
approximately 1% of the general population. Prevalence of aneurysms
may be increased in patients with first-degree relatives with
aneurysms and those with polycystic kidney disease and connective
tissue disorders. Aneu-rysms may be recognized after spontaneous
rupture, through mass effect on adjacent nerves, or may be noted
incidentally on CT or MR imaging performed for other reasons.
Historically, management of these aneurysms has been the domain of
neurosurgeons; however, relatively recent advances in endovascular
therapy highlight the importance of radiologists in the diagnosis
and treatment of cerebral aneurysms.
Clinical management
Patients presenting with ruptured aneurysms present little
dilemma regarding management. In essentially all cases of ruptured
aneurysms, primary therapy is aimed at reducing or eradicating the
risk of rehemorrhage, which approaches 50% at 6 months. Patients
presenting with aneurysms causing mass effect present a more
complex management scheme. Many of these aneurysms occur in the
region of the cavernous sinus, and these aneurysms present little
risk for subsequent rupture. Because of the relatively low risk of
subarachnoid hemorrhage in these patients, management in many cases
may be expectant, with symptoms of double vision ameliorated using
an eye patch.
In contrast to giant aneurysms of the cavernous sinus,
incidently noted aneurysms around the Circle of Willis represent an
extremely challenging clinical algorithm. Although recent data
suggests an extremely low rate of spontaneous hemorrhage in small
aneurysms, aneurysms located at the anterior communicating artery
or the basilar tip, and/or a family history of ruptured aneurysm
may prompt more aggressive management. Many other small aneurysms
may be managed with follow-up imaging alone.
Ruptured aneurysms
For ruptured aneurysms, therapy aimed at closure of aneurysm
cavity is mandatory, since the rehemorrhage rate for ruptured
aneurysms approaches 20% at 2 weeks and 50% at 6 months following
initial hemorrhage. Regardless of initial deficit, rehemorrhage is
devastating in the majority of cases.
Endovascular therapy-Endovascular therapy of aneurysms can be
broadly divided into two types: deconstructive (obliteration of the
parent artery along with the aneurysm) and reconstructive
(intrasaccular occlusion of the aneurysm cavity with preservation
of adjacent vessel). Deconstructive therapy is primarily related to
therapy for giant aneurysms, which will be described in detail
below. Reconstructive therapy is the endovascular approach of
choice for small aneurysms.
Reconstructive, endovascular therapy-Although several modes of
intrasaccular therapies for aneurysms were developed in the past
several decades (including balloons, glues, and various coils), the
advent of the Guglielmi detachable coil (GDC, Target Therapeutics,
Fremont, CA) has revolutionized the endovascular approach to
reconstructive cerebral aneurysm therapy.2,3 The GDC was developed
in the early 1990s and received FDA approval in 1995. The GDC is
manufactured in numerous sizes and shapes, and is constructed of a
soft platinum wire. The platinum renders the coil extremely
radiopaque under fluoroscopic imaging, and is also soft,
atraumatic, and relatively non-thrombogenic. The platinum coil is
welded to a stainless steel pusher wire. The coil can be advanced
out of the catheter for positioning within the aneurysm, and can be
retracted if positioning is suboptimal, usually as a result of
protrusion into the parent artery. Once satisfactory coil
positioning is achieved, a current is passed through the device and
electrolytic detachment occurs several minutes following
application of the current.
The precise coil used to begin embolization is based on the size
and shape of the aneurysm cavity. The diameter of the initial coil
should nearly approximate the diameter of the aneurysm cavity. The
coil is then placed so that coil winds occupy the periphery of the
aneurysm cavity and cross the aneurysm neck. Subsequent coils are
typically smaller in diameter and/or shorter, and are used to fill
in the spaces along the interior of the initial coil. While coils
in numerous sizes, shapes, and softness characteristics are
available, this technique is used in nearly all cases. Coil
embolization continues with the addition of subsequent coils until
the aneurysm is densely packed with platinum. Then the catheter is
removed and control angio-graphy is performed (figures 1 and
2).
Surgery versus endovascular therapy-The choice between surgical
or endovascular therapy is complex, and is based on aneurysm size,
geometry, and location. Many practitioners use coil embolization as
a first-line therapy in basilar tip aneurysms, given the relatively
high surgical mortality associated with these lesions. Conversely,
middle cerebral artery aneurysms are generally more appropriate for
surgical therapy, given the relatively low rates of surgical
complications and the complex anatomy associated with these
aneurysms that makes coil embolization difficult.
Complications of GDC embolization-For ruptured aneurysms, the
overall complication rate of GDC embolization approaches 5% to 7%.4
Most often, such complications are related to thromboembolic
events, which can be minimized by using systemic anticoagulation.
Aneurysm perforation can occur in up to 2% of ruptured aneurysms,
although this rate is lower in unruptured aneurysms. Parent artery
compromise may occur from damage to the coil or protrusion of coil
loops into the parent artery.
Outcomes-Radiographic outcome for coil embolization of cerebral
aneurysms is graded in reference to the degree of aneurysm
occlusion. Although numerous semi-quantitative scales are
available, most scales are divided into complete occlusion,
subtotal occlusion, or partial occlusion. For small aneurysms (<
10 mm diameter), total or near total occlusion is achieved in most
cases. Conversely, for aneurysms 3 5 mm in diameter, the minority
of cases are termed completely or nearly completely occluded.
For ruptured aneurysms, the rate of rehemorrhage following GDC
embolization is approximately 1% to 2% at 6 months, as compared
with the 50% rehemorrhage rate for untreated ruptured aneurysms.
Because the background spontaneous rupture rate for unruptured
aneurysms is extremely low, significant decreases in spontaneous
rupture rate after coil embolization have not yet been proven.
Rate of recanalization is related not only to aneurysm size but
also to the diameter of the aneurysm neck. For large aneurysms or
wide-neck aneurysms (typically aneurysm necks
> 4 mm), occurrence rates are significantly higher compared
with small- or
narrow-neck aneurysms. For small- and narrow-neck aneurysms,
recanalization rates at 3 months are approximately 15%. At the
other end of the spectrum, recannalization for giant aneurysms (3
25 mm in diameter) is on the order of 75% (figure 3). For this
reason, most practitioners will not attempt reconstructive therapy
of giant aneurysms, leaving this to direct surgical therapy or to
deconstructive therapy.9
Follow-up imaging-The platinum used in the GDC makes follow-up
MRI imaging quite safe. Indeed, the degree of susceptibility
artifact from these coils is surprisingly low. Most practitioners
recommend catheter angiography at 6 months following coil
embolization, at which time recurrent aneurysm remnants may be
coiled.
Deconstructive, endovascular therapy-Deconstructive therapy,
otherwise known as parent artery occlusion or Hunterian ligation,
is typically used for large or giant carotid and basilar aneurysms.
The typical aneurysm treated with deconstructive therapy is along
the carotid artery, either in the cavernous carotid artery, which
is extradural, or the supraclinoid internal carotid artery (ICA),
which is intradural. Precise localization of the aneurysm is
extremely important in determining the patient's prognosis. If the
aneurysm is present in an extradural location, the risk of
intracranial hemorrhage is extremely low. Clinical consequences of
these extradural aneurysms include cranial nerve palsies from mass
effect resulting in double vision, carotid cavernous fistulae
resulting from spontaneous decompression of the aneurysm into the
adjacent cavernous sinus, or epistaxis. Patients presenting with
isolated sixth-nerve palsy in the presence of a large or giant
cavernous aneurysm frequently are managed conservatively with an
eye patch. More aggressive therapies may be applied in cases of
rapid growth, erosion into the sphenoid sinus, or multiple cranial
nerve palsy.
Imaging considerations-It is extremely important for the imager
to localize the origin of aneurysms precisely along the distal
carotid artery. Cavernous carotid aneurysms, which are extradural
in location and thus of low or negligible risk for intracranial
hemorrhage, are located along the horizontal portion of the carotid
siphon, and are directed laterally. Medial projections of these
aneurysms typically occur only after the aneurysms have grown to
extremely large size laterally. Conversely, intradural aneurysms
along the distal ICA carry prognostic features identical to those
for berry aneurysms around the Circle of Willis. Intracranial
aneurysms along the distal ICA are generally termed "ophthalmic
segment aneurysms." These intradural aneurysms can arise at the
origin of the ophthalmic artery or may be more distal in location
than the ophthalmic artery, yet not as distal as the origin of the
posterior communicating arteries. The aneurysms between the
ophthalmic and posterior communicating arteries are called
"superior hypophyseal aneurysms." Unlike cavernous aneurysms that
are typically directed laterally, the superior hypophyseal
aneurysms are often directed medially. Smaller aneurysms at the
superior hypophyseal artery typically project anteromedially into
the region of the carotid cave. Larger superior hypophyseal
aneurysms frequently project above the sella. Ophthalmic aneurysms
usually project anterosuperiorly, and are relatively easily
discerned from cavernous aneurysms.
Therapeutic approach-Deconstructive therapy is relevant for
large and giant aneurysms of the distal ICA. Smaller aneurysms of
the distal ICA may be treated with reconstructive approaches as
described above. For giant aneurysms, Hunterian ligation is
preferred. The general approach of deconstructive therapy is to
effect occlusion of the aneurysm cavity. In most cases, occlusion
of the proximal parent artery will achieve occlusion of the
aneurysm cavity. This almost always applies for cavernous
aneurysms, since occlusion of the ICA proximal aneurysm will
achieve closure of the internal artery up to the origin of the
ophthalmic artery, which is distal to the aneurysm sack. Therapy
for ophthalmic and superior hypophyseal giant aneurysms is more
problematic. Occlusion of the ICA proximal to the aneurysm, without
occlusion of the aneurysm sack itself, may allow persistent flow
into the aneurysm from retrograde flow through the ophthalmic
artery in approximately 50% of cases. For these reasons, we often
combine intrasaccular, loose coil embolization with proximal parent
artery occlusion for such aneurysms.
Parent artery occlusion is tolerated in the vast majority of
patients. Test occlusion of the involved artery is mandatory. At
our institution, a non-detachable balloon is inflated in the target
artery for up to 30 minutes. During this time, the patient's blood
pressure is maintained in the normal range, and a detailed
neurologic examination is performed. At the end of this test
occlusion, the temporary balloon is removed, and, if the patient
has tolerated the test, permanent balloon occlusion is performed.
No provocative testing, such as hypotension challenge, or any
functional imaging, such as SPECT imaging, are performed during the
test occlusion. Most often, permanent occlusion of the parent
artery is achieved using balloons, either latex or silicone. In
some cases, it may be preferred to perform coil embolization of the
involved parent artery.
Complications-Regardless of diagnostic maneuvers used during
test occlusion, the stroke risk associated with parent artery
occlusion approaches 5%. These strokes may result from
hypoperfusion or thromboembolic complications, and may occur up to
30 days following the procedure. These complications may be
diminished using systemic anticoagulation in the periprocedural
period, as well strict bed rest for 24 to 48 hours following
balloon occlusion.
Follow up imaging-No specific follow up imaging is performed
after parent artery occlusion.
Conclusion
Management of patients with intracranial aneurysms, whether
presenting with subarachnoid hemorrhage, mass effect, or
incidentally, requires detailed understanding of the therapeutic
options for these cases. Small, incidental aneurysms as well as
large cavernous aneurysms may managed expectantly. Frequently,
small aneurysms presenting with subarachnoid hemorrhage are treated
with intrasaccular coil embolization. Giant aneurysms remain the
domain of parent artery occlusion. AR
References
1. The International Study of Unruptured Intracranial Aneurysms
Investigators: Unruptured intracranial aneurysms: Risks of rupture
and risks of surgical intervention. N Engl J Med 339:1725-1733,
1998.
2. Eskridge JM, Song JK: Endovascular embolization of 150
basilar tip aneurysms with guglielmi detachable coils-Results of
the Food and Drug Administration multicenter clinical trial. J
Neurosurg 89(1):81-86, 1998.
3. Malisch TW, Guglielmi G, Vinuela F, et al: Intracranial
aneurysms treated with the Guglielmi detachable coil-Midterm
clinical results in a consecutive series of 100 patients. J
Neurosurg 87(2):176-183, 1997.
4. Vineula F, Duckwiler G, Mawad M: Gugliemi detachable coil
embolization of acute intracranial aneurysm: Perioperative
anatomical and clincial outcome in 403 patients. J Neurosurg
86:475-482, 1997.
5. Gruber A, Killer M, Bavinzski G, Richling B: Clinical and
angiographic results of endosaccular coiling treatment of giant and
very large intracranial aneurysms: A 7-year, single-center
experience. Neurosurgery 45:793-803, 1999.