In the last two decades, women's health concerns have begun to
be addressed more specifically through several avenues. Largely as
a result of a tremendous outcry from the public, Congress has
designated Department of Defense funds to be earmarked for breast
cancer research. Congress also passed the Mammography Quality
Standards Act (MQSA) in 1992, which went into effect in 1994. The
MQSA required all facilities performing mammography to function at
a basic or standard level of quality that is rigorously enforced
through annual reviews and inspections.1
Since the 1970s, centers devoted to the specific health care
needs of women have emerged; such centers became the most rapidly
growing area of health care services between 1985 and 1988.2 As the
general population's life expectancy and the need for providing
comprehensive health care to women beyond their obstetrical years
increases, the growth of these centers is expected to continue.
Women's health centers offer comprehensive care in an
outpatient, often free-standing setting. The development of such
centers also has been recognized by health care facilities as an
important service to offer. National statistics suggest that in
almost 70% of households, the health care decisions, such as
selection of a center for care, are made for the family members by
women.2 Women's health care centers can offer comprehensive
education, prevention, diagnosis, and sometimes treatment, all
within one location. In such centers, multiple interactions with
various health care providers (including primary care physicians,
nurse practitioners, and specialists) and various diagnostic
evaluations all can occur in one visit. The obvious advantage for
the patient is a more efficient and complete coordination of her
basic health care needs. Such patient-focused delivery of care
which crosses departmental organization is expeditious, well
planned, and allows for rapid communication of findings to all
concerned.
Within the women's health center stands a critical component in
the diagnostic compendium, namely radiology. In this paper we will
discuss our experience with a comprehensive women's health center
in an academic setting.
Overview of the women's health center
Conceptual objectives in planning a women's center should
include providing comprehensive services by experts in a convenient
setting and a patient-focused atmosphere. In our center we seek to
offer integrated clinical and educational services in a
comfortable, caring, and user-friendly environment. Providers from
many disciplines come to the center to share their expertise and
offer their services. This setting provides an excellent
opportunity for linking the main campus academic medical center
with the women's center, to share resources.
The establishment of a consumer-based health care advisory
council is most helpful in planning and implementation of such a
center.2 The women who sit on the council can provide first-hand
information about women's personal health care needs in the
community. As programs are planned and developed, the council can
provide advice as to what services would be of interest to
consumers.
Conceptually, each component and area of the center is patient
focused; all staff members clearly understand and support that
goal. The success of the women's health center is dependent on many
factors, including the integration of services, dedication and
expertise of the staff, sound marketing and outreach to the
community, accessibility of location and hours, and assessment of
patient feedback.2,3
With the larger number of women who work outside the home, an
important planning issue to consider is the advantages of offering
non-traditional clinical hours in the evenings and/or on Saturdays.
Safety and accessibility to the site also are key issues, as
educational programs are often planned for evenings. Central to the
concept of the women's center is the emphasis on health
maintenance, disease prevention, and changing health risk
behaviors. More specifically, increasing the utilization of
screening mammography is one of the fundamental components of the
program.
Physician referral for screening mammograms is an important
incentive to increasing utilization of this procedure.4 Having the
mammography area within or contiguous with a women's health center
readily increases the volume of women who undergo screening on a
regular basis.
A women's center model
Among the clinical services offered in our medical center are
obstetrical care, infertility treatment, perimenopausal care,
breast health and care, adolescent care, internal medicine, and a
range of psychiatric and counseling services. Radiology services
include general radiology, breast imaging, and general ultrasound.
These radiology services are provided to all patients in the
outpatient center, many of whom are seen at the women's health
center, as well as patients referred from private physicians in the
community.
MCV Women's HealthCare, the women's health center at our
institution, is located within a larger, free-standing outpatient
center (figure 1). Portions of the clinical space are shared,
maximizing the efficient use of space and staff. Within the women's
center itself the services include health/clinical, psychosocial,
nutritional, and educational. The departments of Obstetrics and
Gynecology, Internal Medicine, Surgery, Plastic Surgery,
Psychiatry, Genetics, and Radiology from the main medical center
are all represented at the women's center: A primary presence is
maintained daily by faculty from OB/GYN, Internal Medicine and
Radiology, with other services providing scheduled coverage. Nurse
practitioners, a dietician, clinical social workers, and counselors
provide extensive support to the clinical aspects of the
center.
The design of MCV Women's HealthCare is such that the clinical
space flows freely from one area to the next. One advantage of this
is that patients scheduled for a routine gynecologic examination
can be scheduled for annual mammography at the same time. The
hallways of the center are contiguous, allowing easy access of the
gowned patient from one area to the next without the need for
re-dressing, re-registering, etc. For example, a patient with a
palpable finding on her breast exam can be seen immediately in the
radiology area for breast imaging, with a minimum of discomfort or
embarrassment.
The marketing of breast imaging services to the community has
enhanced the growth of the radiology practice and has served as an
additional referral source to the women's center. Patients who are
self requesting or self-referred for screening mammography often
receive their introduction to the array of services offered by the
outpatient center through their mammography appointment. Those
patients with a positive experience in this setting may seek
referral to a primary care physician or gynecologist in the
center.
The radiology services offered at women's centers are far more
comprehensive than just screening mammography. Full-time staffing
by a breast imager ensures that diagnostic mammography (figure 2)
can be directed and performed at any time, providing a more
comprehensive approach to patient care. Breast ultrasound, if
needed, can be performed at the same time as mammography, and the
patient is able to leave the radiology area knowing the results of
her study.
Within the radiology area, instruction in breast self
examination (figure 3) is given by the mammography technologists to
those patients requesting it. The technologists also are key in the
area of patient education during the scheduling of procedures. With
patient-focused care in mind, these technologists provide the
patient with explanations of the procedures and approximate length
of testing time, and allow her to ask any questions she may have.
Patients are given the name and direct phone number of the
interventional technologist, and many do call with questions before
their procedure.
A full range of breast interventional procedures are offered in
the typical women's center, including stereotactic breast biopsy,
cyst aspiration, fine needle aspiration biopsy, ultrasound-guided
core biopsy, galactography, and needle localization. Patients who
are found to have an abnormality on mammography requiring
percutaneous biopsy are informed of the findings and are scheduled
for the procedure. The referring physician is consulted regarding
the recommendation at the same time. Patients who require a
surgical consultation are scheduled with a surgical oncologist, who
can see patients right there in the center, if desired. This rapid
response to the patient with an abnormality greatly expedites her
care and alleviates much of the anxiety associated with waiting for
the various steps in the process, such as results of mammography,
results of sonography, a call from the referring physician, a
scheduled appointment for biopsy, etc.
When tests on patients from the women's health center
demonstrate an abnormality, referring physicians or nurse
practitioners are available for consultation, often before the
patients are ready to leave the building.
In cases of imaging an abnormality, the results of the biopsy
can be conveyed directly to the patient, as well as to her
physician, by the radiologist. Patients with malignant diagnoses
are told in person, and need not be called with the results by
phone. The radiologist can then spend time explaining the next
step, and may even set up the appointment with the surgical
oncologist so that care is complete and the patient is not left to
sort out the information and schedules for herself.
The Breast Health component of MCV Women's HealthCare is staffed
by surgical oncology and is a satellite of the much larger Breast
Health Center in the Cancer Center at the main campus. The Breast
Health Center is a multidisciplinary center in which surgical
staff, radiation and medical oncologists, pathologists,
radiologists, and nurses come together to discuss findings and plan
care for the patient. Those patients seen at the satellite breast
center have already had their radiographs and data evaluated at the
multidisciplinary Breast Center in advance, and are afforded the
expertise of a comprehensive, multidisciplinary opinion within the
quiet, private framework of the women's health center.
Other imaging services provided in radiology include general
ultrasound and radiography. Male and female patients of all ages
are seen for these procedures, yet the design of the department,
with separate areas for patient dressing booths and waiting,
maintains the private women's health focus of the breast imaging
area.
Although rather small in terms of number of staff and pieces of
equipment, the area is highly efficient and productive. The
technologists, clerical staff, and physicians operate as a team,
with the patient as the focal point. Technologists oversee clerical
and file room staff, ensuring that patients are moving quickly from
reception into the clinical area and verifying that reports are
completed, signed, and sent. This crossing over of the duties
enhances the quality of the entire operation and improves the
utilization of staff. Yet within this productive framework each
patient is meant to feel that she is not being rushed through, that
her questions are being answered, and that she was provided with
the quality of services that she deserved and sought.
A computerized database is utilized for reporting mammography
and for the medial audit required by the MQSA. In our center, the
computerized patient reporting and tracking database for
mammography patients also is utilized to generate recall letters to
patients. The use of such reminders is advantageous in improving
the regular utilization of screening by women.5
Conclusion:
As the population of women in midlife grows, there is increasing
need for high quality women's health care services that provide
comprehensive efficient care in a single location. This concept
requires rethinking the traditional departmental organization,
remaining patient focused, and bringing various specialists
together. Radiology is a key component to these centers; in
particular, the comprehensive breast imaging services can enhance
the mission of improving the health of women. AR
Acknowledgement
The authors gratefully acknowledge the excellent assistance of
Ms. Susan Ross in the preparation of the manuscript.
References
1. 21 CFR Part 900: Mammography Facility- Requirements for
Accrediting Bodies and Quality Standards and Certification
Requirements; Interim Rules: Federal Register, Washington, DC
12/21/1993 58: (243) 67558-67572.
2. Hardigan EO: The development of a women's health center is an
academic health center. College Review A C MGA: 10(2):5-20,
1993.
3. Knight D: Hospital women's centers that work. Health Care
Strategic Management 1214, 1988.
4. Rimer BK: Mammography use in the US: Trends and the impact of
interventions: Ann Behav Med 16:317-326, 1994.
5. Taplin SH, Anderman C, Grothaus L, et al: Using physician
correspondence and postcard reminders to provide mammography use.
Am J Publ Health 84:571-574, 1994.
Dr. deParedes is Professor of Radiology and Director of Breast
Imaging at the Medical College of Virginia of Virginia Commonwealth
University in Richmond. She is also a member of the editorial
advisory board of this journal. Dr. Klein is Assistant Professor of
Internal Medicine, and Ms. Collins is Associate
Professor Emeritus in the Department of Ob/Gyn and Director of
MCV Women's HealthCare, also at the Medical College of Virginia of
Virginia Commonwealth University.