Jury Awards $2 Million in Malpractice Suit Over Misinterpreted Ultrasound

A Florida jury has ruled in favor of a couple, awarding them $2 million following the stillbirth of their child, which was attributed to a misinterpreted ultrasound. The case highlighted the role of a 20-week fetal anatomy ultrasound, which was interpreted by a radiologist at Radiology Regional in Lee County, Florida. Although the sonographer's notes mentioned difficulties in visualizing the baby's face, lips, and nose, the radiologist reported no facial or oral abnormalities.

The parents argued that if the severe facial deformity had been detected, the mother’s prenatal care would have shifted from a midwife to an obstetrician, which aligns with the standard of care practices. This transition might have addressed the condition more effectively. At 38 weeks, the mother developed preeclampsia and delivered a stillborn baby. Post-delivery examinations revealed a severe cleft deformity that had not been diagnosed beforehand.

The trial, lasting one week, concluded with jurors granting a seven-figure compensation to the plaintiffs. The family's legal representatives noted that Radiology Regional did not propose a settlement before or during the trial proceedings. The defense contended that the midwife, who was responsible for the mother's care, should bear the brunt of the responsibility rather than the radiologist who interpreted the ultrasound.

In a statement, Ryan Fogg, managing partner of Fogg Law Group, expressed that the verdict represents a significant outcome for a family facing such profound loss. "This verdict brings justice to a family who suffered a great loss," Fogg stated on July 9. "We were able to determine that the death of this child was preventable. This verdict represents two parents who never gave up on their daughter, even after she passed."

The case underscores the critical role of accurate prenatal imaging in managing fetal health and ensuring timely and appropriate medical care transitions when abnormalities are suspected.